The limits of employee engagement

By Gabe Scorgie

6 min read

The limits of employee engagement
Illustration by Jimmy Foulds

No matter how much organizations strive to engage their employees, every business will eventually reach a point where engagement levels plateau. But this doesn’t necessarily mean that all hope is lost.

Employee engagement is a critical component of organizational success, with engaged workers being more productive, present, and loyal than their disengaged counterparts. Recognizing this, modern workplaces have significantly emphasized increasing employee engagement levels.

This blog aims to examine the boundaries and limitations of employee engagement and other strategies organizations can use to go beyond the plateau.

Defining Employee Engagement

At its heart, employee engagement is about getting employees to buy into the company’s mission and values. This investment manifests as enthusiasm, energy, loyalty, and commitment to the organization’s goals.

Some of the key components of employee engagement include:

  • Creating an organizational culture that fosters collaboration and creativity
  • Recognizing employees’ efforts and achievements, both publicly and privately
  • Encouraging feedback and open communication
  • Offering employees meaningful rewards for their hard work

When combined with a carefully crafted employee engagement plan, organizations can reap the benefits of increased productivity, higher morale and job satisfaction, reduced turnover rates, and an improved bottom line.

In recent years, organizations have executed the most popular strategies for boosting employee engagement. These are generally based on intrinsic motivation, such as organizing rewards and recognition programs, providing flexible work schedules, creating a feedback culture, and offering career development opportunities.

Get stories like this in your inbox


Benefits of employee engagement

With less than a third of employees feeling genuinely engaged at work, putting in the effort to create an environment where employees feel valued, appreciated, and respected can go a long way toward lifting your organization above the competition.

Increased productivity and efficiency in the workplace

Most employees are motivated to do their best work when they feel appreciated and valued. They tend to be more productive and energetic, increasing efficiency and cost-effectiveness.

Highly engaged employees are also more likely to make consistent (or even extra) efforts when needed, making them invaluable to the organization.

Positive impact on employee satisfaction, well-being, and retention rates

High levels of employee engagement are associated with greater job satisfaction, as engaged employees tend to have a higher sense of purpose and fulfillment in their work. They are less likely to look for other opportunities elsewhere, reducing costly turnover rates and disruption in operations.

A more positive work environment can result in healthier, happier employees inside and out, reducing stress levels and boosting morale.

Improved teamwork, collaboration, and innovation

Employee engagement is not just about keeping people happy—it’s also about growing an environment that encourages creativity, collaboration, and innovation.

An engaged workforce is more likely to develop creative solutions to problems, confide in each other, and work together as a team. This ultimate combination leads to better execution of ideas, fewer mistakes, and higher success rates.

Enhanced customer satisfaction and loyalty

Engaged employees often display higher levels of commitment to the company’s vision and goals, making them ideal ambassadors for the brand. As a result, they are more likely to provide excellent customer service, which leads to enhanced customer satisfaction and a higher lifetime value.

Exploring the limits of employee engagement

While employee engagement is critical to any successful business strategy, it can only go so far in influencing job satisfaction and performance. It also isn’t easy to maintain long-term since it requires significant effort and resources to keep employees engaged.

Companies often find themselves stuck as they try to push the limits without realizing they can’t cross certain boundaries.

For instance, an organization may offer competitive salaries and benefits packages, provide flexible work arrangements, or even offer a variety of perks such as free meals or onsite gyms. However, these things are only valuable to employees up to a certain point.

Recognizing the individual limitations and preferences of employees

Maintaining personal and professional boundaries paves the way for a more effective and meaningful engagement. Knowing individual limits and preferences allows a better understanding of what the employee can and is willing to do.

The potential for burnout and stress due to excessive expectations can also strain employee engagement. It’s crucial to be mindful that there is a limit to how much work employees can take on, and pushing them too far can have negative results.

The role of enablement in the workplace 

An employee survey by Microsoft found that meaningful missions and empowerment are two major components of thriving at work. An enabling workplace culture where individuals feel empowered and energized to take initiative is essential for fostering employee engagement.

But if employees aren’t enabled, meaning their ideas are not being heard or put into action, it can lead to feelings of frustration, apathy, and, ultimately, disengagement. 

The role of celebration in the workplace

Like meaningful work, employees need to feel that what they contribute matters. A huge part of this is recognizing their efforts and celebrating their successes. Positive reinforcement is an effective tool that encourages employees to keep up the good work and strive for more.

However, too much celebration can also backfire, as it can lead to a sense of overconfidence and complacency. The key is to find the right balance between celebrating accomplishments and targeting current goals.

Finding the optimal balance

Unfortunately, even the most successful efforts toward employee engagement will eventually hit a point where it becomes ineffective. This point of diminished returns happens naturally as the same incentives and once fruitful activities start to become less meaningful.

For organizations to address the engagement gap, they must be willing to take a step back and assess their current strategies. 

  • Are they still effective? 
  • What changes will reinvigorate employee enthusiasm? 

They must be open to new ideas and willing to experiment with different approaches.

Recognizing that employees have individual limitations, needs, and preferences can go a long way toward achieving better results. Simply put, what works for one might not work for another. Embrace flexibility and adaptability to account for these differences, and ensure no one feels left out or taken advantage of.

Another aspect of engagement is promoting work-life balance to nurture employee well-being. Not only does it help cultivate a healthier working atmosphere, but it also helps increase productivity, performance, and overall job satisfaction.

Equally important as engagement and recognition, enablement pushes employees to do more and feel more empowered. Giving them the tools, resources, and support they need to develop their skills and perform optimally will help create a culture of collaboration and ownership over their work.

Beyond employee engagement: the role of employee success

As counterintuitive as it may seem, bumping into limits of employee engagement is not necessarily bad, as this plateau can indicate that the organization has achieved a certain level of success.

But relying on employee engagement to keep employees motivated isn’t always enough. The bigger picture of employee success, which encompasses enablement and celebration, is more beneficial and sustainable in the long run.

Aiming for employee success as a holistic approach to employee well-being and satisfaction creates an environment where employees thrive and feel empowered to contribute more.

From providing employees with the resources they need to succeed to celebrating small and big accomplishments, organizations can gradually build a culture of success that will continue to motivate and engage employees.


Employee engagement remains essential to business success as it encourages employees to be more productive, innovative, and loyal. However, organizations must know that it can only take them so far.

Certain limits and boundaries exist, not only in terms of the degree and quality of engagement that can be achieved but also in the strategies that can be used to sustain it.

Adopting a more comprehensive approach to enhancing employee well-being and experience through engagement, enablement, and celebration can help organizations get ahead of the plateau and achieve employee success.


A focus on employee success boosts productivity and joy

Find out how

Gabe Scorgie

  • Share this:

Add your comments